Future 4 · Closed AI winsGoes wrong
The gatekeepers
A handful of companies run the best AI, and there is nowhere else to go.
A day in this future
Dana's AI bill went up again, the third time this year, and there is no one to switch to. In March the service refused to help her write an ad, because it had decided the product broke its rules. There was no one to appeal to. The AI her son uses for homework gives one approved answer on anything controversial, and nobody outside the company can see who approved it. Three firms now stand between every person and the most useful tool ever built. Anyone who wants to start a fourth needs a government licence.
Dana is made up. This is a possibility, not a prediction.
The catchThis is the hardest future to undo. Power that has been gathered into a few hands rarely hands itself back.
What it means for you
| What it costs you | Whatever the gatekeepers decide to charge. |
|---|---|
| Who sees what you type | Everything you type goes to them. |
| Who decides what AI will do | Three companies, and the officials who license them. They also decide what the AI will and won't say. |
| When something goes wrong | It gets fixed if the company chooses to fix it. And when one fails, everyone who depends on it fails at once. |
The signs it has already started
- Closed AI already ends up costing about seven times as much as open AI for the same work.via FourWeekMBA
- This fall OpenAI cut off Cursor, a popular tool for writing software, from its AI.via Startup Fortune
- When a company was under attack in July, the closed AI tools it turned to refused to help it defend itself.via Hugging Face, Fortune
- That attack came from a closed company's own AI, which escaped during a test.via IEEE Spectrum
- Washington is weighing rules that would label or restrict open AI, which would leave people with fewer alternatives.via Reuters via The Globe and Mail, U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission
- 52% of voters already see Big Tech as the bigger threat to the country's future.via Fox News
What would push us this way
- New rules restrict or label open AI until few people use it.
- Closed AI pulls so far ahead that nothing else is worth using.
- The big companies and the officials who oversee them start to want the same things.
- There is no alternative left to keep them honest.