OpenvsClosed.aiGet updates

Home / The four futures

Future 3 · Closed AI winsGoes right

The trusted few

A handful of companies run the best AI, and they earn the trust.

A day in this future

Dana pays one monthly fee, like a phone plan, and the AI just works. When a flaw was found last year that let scammers misuse it, the company fixed it for everyone overnight. A handful of big companies make the AI, and independent inspectors test each new version before it is released. The money those companies earned paid for the research that caught her mother's cancer early. Dana has never once wondered where the AI runs.

Dana is made up. This is a possibility, not a prediction.

The catchIt lasts only as long as the people in charge stay careful and fair. Nothing in this future lets you leave if they stop.

What it means for you

What it costs youA monthly bill, kept in check because a few companies compete for your business.
Who sees what you typeWhat you type goes to the company, under strict rules about what it can do with it.
Who decides what AI will doA few companies, watched by independent inspectors.
When something goes wrongThe company fixes it for everyone at once, or switches it off.

The signs it has already started

  • The most capable AI today is closed. Open AI is 4 to 10 months behind it.via Epoch AI, Håvard Tveit Ihle
  • A closed AI can be fixed or switched off by its maker. The off-switch bills in Congress would only work on closed AI.via CNBC
  • California, New York and Illinois already require safety reports from the biggest AI companies.via American Enterprise Institute
  • Closed AI collects about 73% of the money, which pays for the next round of research.via OpenRouter

What would push us this way

  • Several closed companies keep competing hard, so prices keep falling.
  • Independent safety testing is real and has teeth.
  • The companies are held responsible when their AI causes harm.
  • Open AI stays legal, so there is always somewhere else to go.

The other three futures

Find out when the future shifts

One short email when a law changes or one of the four futures gets closer. Nothing else.

Want to weigh in? Build a letter to your representative.