OpenvsClosedGet updates

Home / How this works

How this site works

We back open AI and we say so. The site is only useful if you can see how we reach what we say.

The four futures are scenarios

Nobody knows what happens next. The four futures are the four ways it can go: AI ends up mostly open or mostly closed, and that turns out well or badly. The people in the stories are made up. Everything listed under “the signs it has already started” is a real event with a source you can open.

What counts as open

An AI model is open if anyone can download it and run it themselves, even if it comes with some conditions. It is closed if you can only use it through its maker's app or website. Our grades show that some open AI comes with more strings than others.

How news is marked

  • Future 1, AI for everyone: open AI is protected in law, tested properly, or built by more countries and companies.
  • Future 2, Nobody's in charge: open AI is shown to be unsafe, or is misused, and nobody can be held responsible.
  • Future 3, The trusted few: closed AI pulls ahead, or is tested, held to account or made to compete.
  • Future 4, The gatekeepers: open AI is banned, limited or labelled, buyers are pushed off it, or a closed company cuts people off.

When a development only makes open AI or closed AI stronger, without telling us whether that goes well or badly, it is marked with both futures on that side.

How the compass moves

We take every news item from the last 30 days. Each one counts once. If it pushes toward two futures, each gets half. The compass lights up the future with the highest count and shows the count for all four. It is a count of what happened. It is not a forecast, and a single big event can matter more than ten small ones.

Last 30 days · 10 news items

The news is pushing hardest toward Future 4: The gatekeepers.

Of 10 news items in the last 30 days, 4 pushed toward it. Future 1, AI for everyone, is next with 3.5.

An item that pushes toward two futures counts as half for each. How this works.

Sources and corrections

Every fact links to where it came from, and the full source list is public. We prefer the original document to a news story about it. If we got something wrong, tell us and we'll fix it and say that we did.

Who pays for this

Open vs Closed is independent. No AI company funds it. More about the site.

Use the data

Everything on this site comes from one file. Take it: data.json. There is also a feed of news items and an embeddable compass.

Find out when the future shifts

One short email when a law changes or one of the four futures gets closer. Nothing else.

Want to weigh in? Build a letter to your representative.